Dear Vice Chancellor
A letter written by Cicatrice and fellow University of Sheffield students in response to the creative writing department cuts.
Dear Vice Chancellor Keith Burnett,
We are a group of PhD, MA and BA students, university staff and alumni in the School of English at the University of Sheffield. We are very concerned to learn that funding for replacing both the Professor of Poetry and lecturer in Fiction Writing in the department has been withdrawn leaving only one full-time tutor, the poet and academic Dr. Ágnes Lehóczky.
​
Many of us chose Sheffield for our Masters and PhD studies because we were inspired and encouraged by the excellent teaching we experienced during our undergraduate and post-graduate courses in the English department. Working with Vahni Capildeo, Ágnes Lehóczky, Simon Armitage, Alice Honor Gavin and others has been invaluable, allowing us to develop our craft and creativity in an atmosphere combining academic rigour with imaginative breadth. We were therefore greatly looking forward to working with Professor Denise Riley and were dismayed to learn that she will not, after all, be continuing to work at this university. Furthermore, no replacement is now scheduled for the fiction writer post, left vacant since the departure of Alice Honor Gavin a year ago. We believe that this decision will deter other students from pursuing studies in creative writing at Sheffield to the detriment of the School of English and the university as a whole. We respectfully request that this short-sighted decision be reconsidered.
​
You once said, Vice-Chancellor, with regard to the hiring of Simon Armitage to the University of Sheffield in 2011, that ‘The School of English Literature, Language and Linguistics at the University of Sheffield provides an excellent quality of education for our students.’ In the knowledge of current decisions we are now forced to question your personal definition of excellence and quality.
​
Denise Riley is an internationally renowned philosopher and poet with an unparalleled influence on both feminist theory and creative writing today. She has almost fifty years of exemplary publications in both disciplines and poetics itself and has proven to be an engaging, dedicated and inspiring tutor with decades of teaching experience. We were horrified to learn that, despite her commitment to the role and reports of her ‘excellence’ from students on the MA course, she would not be offered a permanent position at the University of Sheffield. It is a testament to the esteem in which she is held that, on the 27th of April, Sheffield University’s Centre for Poetry and Poetics, in collaboration with Bangor University and UEA, hosted a symposium in honour of Professor Riley, as well as launching an anthology, The World Speaking Back, which pays tribute to her work as a poet and academic. Ninety-four distinguished poets have contributed to this publication, while writers and academics from across the UK spoke at the hugely successful event.
​
Were there a suitable replacement for Denise, of which few exist globally, the decision might have been justified, but we are aware that the university will not be hiring anyone to cover either Denise’s current role or the recently departed Alice Honor Gavin’s position as fiction writing tutor. It appears there will now be just one active permanent academic and creative writing staff member in the School of English to oversee all BA, MA and PhD students. This is an impossible workload for any one individual; to expect this of Dr. Lehóczky is absurd and unacceptable. All levels of university education will be impacted by this decision, to the point where it would be dishonest to even claim that the university has an active creative writing department.
​
When Sheffield Hallam University is offering writing residencies in Canada and Croatia for its BA students, and many other universities in the north like Leeds and Manchester are investing heavily in the future of creative writing tutoring, we’re forced to question why The University of Sheffield is taking so many steps backwards. With The Centre for Poetry and Poetics, Route 57, Blackbox Manifold and alumni-led projects like Cicatrice Journal, Sheffield university creative writing affiliates are making a huge impact both locally and nationally, having collaborated with The Poetry Business, The National Railway Museum and many others. With this shrinkage of staff future projects such as these, which provide students with vital publication platforms as well as editing, producing and publishing experience crucial to many post-graduate careers, will also inevitably be debased. As students, this financial severing has already been felt in the last academic year and will only worsen following these removals without adequate replacement. There is no defensible rationale for not offering Denise Riley a full-time position following Simon Armitage’s hasty departure, nor for Alice Honor Gavin’s role not to be offered to a similarly qualified writer or academic.
​
Signed below are students, staff members, alumni and other concerned individuals strongly opposed to this butchering which stretches the creative writing department of the university, which was once celebrated, to its breaking point. As a man with ‘special interests’ in culture and poetry, we urge you to reconsider these cuts.
Yours sincerely,
​
Samuel Kendall (Cicatrice Journal)
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Rebecca Sandeman (Cicatrice Journal)
Creative Writing PhD Student
Joe Kriss (Wordlife)
School of English Alumni
Geraldine Monk
Poet and University of Sheffield Affiliate
Katie Smart
MA English Literature Alumni
Upamanyu Das
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Ryan Bramley (WRoCAH)
ESRC DTP PhD Student
​
Ellie Pearce
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Lorenza Shabe
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Rebecca Watson
English Undergraduate (1st Year)
​
Claudia Downs
English Undergraduate (3rd Year)
​
Aidan Jenner-Green
School of English Alumni
​
Nora Murphy
MA Creative Writing Student
​
Hannah Robinson
English Undergraduate (2nd Year)
Dylan Jones
English Undergraduate (2nd Year)
Christina Stimson
MA Creative Writing Alumni
Huw Williams
English Undergraduate (2nd Year)
Isaac Stovell
University of Sheffield Alumni
Lauryn Green
English Undergraduate (1st Year)
​
Letitia Gaskin
English Undergraduate (1st Year)
​
Taylor Waddle
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Yioulia Nikolau
English Undergraduate (1st Year)
Alicia Barnes
MA 19th Century Studies Student
Grace Cohen
School of English Alumni
Loma Sylvana
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Peter Dorey
Creative Writing PhD
​
Evie Wilson
MA Creative Writing Student
​
Daniel Turner
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Lucy Hamilton
Creative Writing PhD
​
Karl Riordan
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Georgie Beardmore
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Ashley Bullen-Cutting
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Andy Buddery
School of English Alumni
​
Rich Woodall
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Helen Angell
MA Creative Writing Student
​
Rachel M Fox
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Ewan Brett
English Undergraduate (2nd Year)
​
Chad Bentley
Creative Writing PhD Student
​
Chantelle Campling
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Melissa Bence
English Undergraduate (2nd Year)
​
Caitlin Thompson
MA English Literature Student
​
Anya Portus
English Undergraduate (2nd Year)
​
Joshua Keane
MA Creative Writing Student
​
Jack Redfern
English Undergraduate (1st Year)
​
Gary Hughes
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Billy Raine
English Undergraduate (2nd Year)
​
Tim Plant
MA Creative Writing Alumni
Jenny Donnison
Creative Writing PhD
​
Vera Fibisan
Creative Writing PhD Student
​
Matthew Cheeseman (Former Route 57 Editor)
Senior Creative Writing Lecturer (UoDerby)
​
Alan Halsey
Poet and University of Sheffield Affiliate
​
Alex Marsh (WRoCAH)
Creative Writing PhD Student
​
James Roberts
MA Creative Writing Student
​
Amber McNamrara
Creative Writing PhD Student
​
Jo Hanlon
MA Creative Writing Student
​
Amy Kinsman
MA Creative Writing Student
​
Pete Green
Poet and University Staff
​
Benjamin Dorey (WRoCAH)
Creative Writing PhD Student
​
Timothy Moffatt
School of English PhD Student
​
Ali Hayward
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Christina Stimson
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Margot Wilson
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Imi Davies
School of English Alumni
​
Nicola Wallace
MA Creative Writing Alumni
​
Sarah Sharp
School of English Alumni
​
Nina Ward
MA Creative Writing Student
​
Russell Dobson
University of Sheffield Alumni
​
Tara Ghaemi
School of English Alumni
​
Sophie Hamilton
School of English Alumni
​
Sam Wadkin
School of English Alumni
​
Emily France
MA Creative Writing Alumni